Why Overpricing Your Brevard County Home Could Cost You Thousands

Podcast episode 158 featuring Nicholas Hall and Lindsay Schellhorn discussing if your home is overpriced.

Table of Contents

The Hidden Cost of Overpricing in Today’s Market

Overpricing your home may seem like a good idea — after all, who doesn’t want to get top dollar?
But in today’s Brevard County real estate market, that strategy could actually cost you thousands.

According to Nick Hall, Realtor with the Selling 321 Team powered by EXP, overpricing is one of the most common (and costly) mistakes homeowners make when selling their property.

“We’re coming out of a market where homes sold instantly, often for more than asking,” Nick explains. “But today, buyers are price-conscious. The same listing strategy that worked in 2021 doesn’t work in 2025.”


What Happens When You Overprice a Home

When a home is listed above fair market value, it doesn’t just sit longer — it sends a message to buyers that something is “off.”
The longer a property stays active, the more likely buyers are to think it’s overvalued or problematic.

Nick Hall breaks it down simply:

“If you overprice your home, you’ll likely end up selling for less than it’s actually worth.”

In the current market, first impressions are everything. Most buyers view listings online before visiting in person, so a property that’s overpriced won’t even make their shortlist.


How the Right Pricing Strategy Sells Homes Faster

As both a seasoned real estate professional and a registered trainee appraiser, Nick Hall approaches pricing with a balance of data and experience.

He uses a method that considers:

  • Comparable home sales (comps) in the area

  • Buying patterns across the last 2–3 years

  • Seasonal demand trends specific to Brevard County

  • Days on market data and shifts in buyer activity

This combination helps sellers understand what their home is truly worth — not just what they wish it were worth.

“Pricing is both an art and a science,” Nick says. “It’s about understanding the numbers while connecting with the seller’s goals and motivations.”


Real-Life Examples: Overpriced vs. Priced Right

❌ Example 1: The Overpriced Listing

A seller in a popular Brevard neighborhood wanted to “test the market” at a higher price.
After six weeks, plenty of showings, and no offers — the property remained unsold.
As Nick likes to say, “The math isn’t mathing.”

✅ Example 2: The Smartly Priced Listing

Another seller, motivated to move quickly, agreed to list just below market value.
Within 48 hours, the home received multiple offers, sold for full price, and even closed early.

The result? Less stress, more profit, and a smoother transaction for everyone involved.


Tips for Sellers: How to Price Your Home the Right Way

Here are Nick Hall’s top tips for homeowners getting ready to list their property:

1. Lead With Empathy

Selling a home is personal. Understanding why someone is moving helps shape realistic goals.

2. Be Data-Driven

Rely on facts, not feelings. Recent comps and trends give you a true picture of what buyers will pay.

3. Price to Attract, Not to Test

Homes priced at or slightly below market value create excitement and competition — often leading to higher offers.

4. Communicate Constantly

Pricing isn’t a one-time conversation. Stay open to adjustments as market conditions evolve.


Why It Matters for Brevard County Homeowners

The Brevard County housing market has shifted since the pandemic boom.
While prices remain strong, buyers are more informed, cautious, and selective than ever before.

Homes that sit on the market lose value over time — both financially and in perception.
Correct pricing gives your property the best chance to stand out, sell quickly, and maximize return.


Work With Experts Who Understand the Local Market

At Morgan Financial, we partner with top agents like Nick Hall to help homeowners navigate every step of the selling process — from pricing to closing.

Featured Agent

Nick Hall | Selling 321 powered by eXp Realty 📞 (772) 213-0675 | ✉️ nickgetsresults@gmail.com

📞 Contact Morgan Financial today to start your home selling journey with confidence.

Joe

Chief Operating Officer

Joe Harris is the COO of Morgan Financial, where he oversees operations, sales, and marketing to ensure a fast, enjoyable, and consistent mortgage experience. With more than 25 years in the industry and over $1 billion funded, Joe combines deep expertise with a passion for helping clients achieve homeownership. He is also dedicated to training and equipping loan officers with the tools and strategies they need to thrive in a competitive market.

NMLS#322991